December 17, 2008

Hallelujah Redux

PRI's The World covered the story of the dueling Hallelujah's today.  The jist: "Music fans are using the internet as a battleground to campaign for their favorite cover version of Leonard Cohen's 1984 love song 'Hallelujah'" - this particular battle pits the winner of Britain's X-Factor (a UK American Idol I am told) against hardcore Jeff Buckley fans who despair of the sacrilege of a version other than Buckley's topping the charts, all of this is made more "exciting" as the coveted Christmas #1 spot is at stake here .  (Cohen fans are apparently content knowing that Leonard is cashing fat royalty checks.)

Those playing along at home will remember that a similar phenomenon occurred during this years American Idol here in the states, which I (among others) noticed and mentioned previously here.

Here's Burke's live version from X-Factor ("official" studio version is here with embed disabled):


Here's Buckley's live version (the "official" studio version is here with embed disabled):


The money is on Burke at the moment but Buckley isn't far behind and I like the look of this dark horse who has quite a following.

2 comments:

a conversationalist said...

Big fan of the Buckley version, but the "Alexandra" one is the closest thing to a second that I have heard. She gets points for making it her own, whereas others who have done it try to sound "Buclleyish"

Teman Poker said...

Agen Bola Online
Bandar Bola Euro 2016